In 2011 the level of public spending on the welfare state by the British Government accounted for £113.1 billion, or 16% of government. By 2020 welfare spending will rise to 1/3rd of all spending making it the largest expense followed by housing benefit, council tax benefit, benefits to the unemployed, and benefits to people with low incomes.
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Political party:
@8RRGF8B4yrs4Y
Make welfare available only to legal citizens.
@8LLDWG74yrs4Y
No changes needed and deny benefits to non-citizens
@8RRGJVD4yrs4Y
Make benefits available to only legal citizens.
@8HGQJHF4yrs4Y
there should be fewer restrictions of welfare benefits for the poor, disabled, most unfortunate people, etc.
Deleted3yrs3Y
Regardless, reform the system so that it rewards, not penalizes, getting a job.
@9334YP33yrs3Y
Welfare should be abolished entirely and replaced by voluntary charity.
Deleted2yrs2Y
More, but welfare should be ended, and instead the federal government should fund and support local private charities and nonprofits
Deleted2yrs2Y
Welfare should be ended, and instead the federal government should fund and support local private charities and nonprofits
Deleted4yrs4Y
It should only be given to citizens who actually need it and are planning on getting off it. Should never be life long.
Deleted4yrs4Y
Only give it to people that need it
Deleted4yrs4Y
Only give it to those who actually need it.
Deleted3yrs3Y
Fewer, replace welfare with UBI
Deleted4yrs4Y
Deleted3yrs3Y
Give it to people that actually need it. These systems should not be abused.
@heatherdvdprincess3yrs3Y
More. We should raise the minimum wage to a beginner's living wage and only provide welfare to those who are incapable of working and for up to 6 months in between jobs. People with repairable conditions should be actively getting treatment and doing all that they can to support themselves. The government should find ways besides direct funding from the government to help people get treatment when they can't afford it. For example, they can ask people to donate to charity, do crowdsourcing and crowdfunding, and hire a paid or unpaid (volunteer) worker to find ways to make money for the person, such as through GoFundMe.
@4P355J93yrs3Y
More, but institute a universal basic income
@4BTMM7B4yrs4Y
Give people a Universal Basic Income and allow them to choose which option is best for them.
@4TGBF234yrs4Y
Privatize social security and eliminate other welfare benefits
@3GZTJR24yrs4Y
More, and ensure benefits go to those that need it most and not to those who abuse the system. In addition, for those who are able to work reform the system so that it supplements, rather than replaces, a working income.
@4W5HV6N4yrs4Y
Get rid of all welfare programs. Replace with socialized healthcare and UBI. Citizens have a choice between one or the other.
@5643HNN4yrs4Y
The current system should be replaced with a Universal Basic Income that supplements a working income, while continuing to help those "get by" who have lost their job in the interim
@69NVLPV3yrs3Y
Eliminate all existing welfare programs and replace them with a monthly income stipend for all citizen households
@8QZF9F64yrs4Y
Abolish the entire welfare system.
@ISIDEWITH3mos3MO
@ISIDEWITH3mos3MO
@ISIDEWITH3mos3MO
@ISIDEWITH3mos3MO
@ISIDEWITH3mos3MO
@ISIDEWITH3mos3MO
@ISIDEWITH3mos3MO
@ISIDEWITH3mos3MO
@ISIDEWITH3mos3MO
@ISIDEWITH3mos3MO
@4XD28G74yrs4Y
More to ensure that it isn't being taken advantage of. However we should increase benefits for those that need it most (ie. the elderly, disabled, and struggling families with children)
@88LK76J3yrs3Y
Deny benefits for single parents
@88LK76J3yrs3Y
Abolish the current welfare system and replace it with universal basic income.
@8WVSFDZ3yrs3Y
The whole system needs revamping so that people with actual disability get the help they need to get off welfare, and so that the paltry amount paid actually provides value.
@jennamarie4yrs4Y
change based on what is working and what isn't working based on each persons situation. If said person needs skills, education, transportation, child care, etc. Implement programs to support the person for personal success (teach a man to fish). Vs. the elderly and disabled may require different programs/support.
@8CS4GM74yrs4Y
Emphasize health coverage benefits. There should not be tens of millions of uninsured American citizens under any circumstances.
@8R2RMP34yrs4Y
More, and ensure benefits go to those that need it the most.
@8R2RMP34yrs4Y
More, and ensure that benefits go to those that need it the most.
@8CNM93J3yrs3Y
Regardless, implement a Negative Income Tax.
@8ZK5HYT3yrs3Y
More, but I would prefer to end all social welfare programs
@92JXK3J2yrs2Y
Too many fakers. We need to reform the system to root out fakers and immigrant non-citizens and those trying to avoid work and ensure that legal citizens who are genuinely trying to find work but can't receive welfare. So right now, I lean towards more. But whatever ensures reform sometimes.
@8H4DF7B4yrs4Y
Only allow welfare benefits if the person has a disability or if they have shown that they have tried to get and keep a job, including going to rehab for drug addiction, but have not been able to keep one. If they refuse to try to get a job then allow them to go to a shelter for people experiencing homelessness. Increase funding and safety precautions and living conditions for those. Only allow non communal (same gender or family in communal) living if they have a disability or have not been able to keep a job despite trying.
@8TPZHT73yrs3Y
Fewer, and abolish currency
@93HQYDF2yrs2Y
Entitlement expenditures must be reduced but either by capping total allocations or by across-the-board reductions of the number of people who qualify, not through subjecting recipients to even more red tape.
@IINXMP4yrs4Y
More, and abolish some welfare programs.
@heatherdvdprincess4yrs4Y
More. We should raise the minimum wage to a beginner's living wage and only provide welfare to those who are incapable of working. People with repairable conditions should be actively getting treatment and doing all that they can to support themselves. The government should find ways besides direct funding from the government to help people get treatment when they can't afford it. For example, they can ask people to donate to charity, do crowdsourcing and crowdfunding, and hire a paid or unpaid (volunteer) worker to find ways to make money for the person, such as through GoFundMe.
@3XKTWPH2yrs2Y
Fewer, but deny benefits to llegal immigrants
@4SNPK4B3yrs3Y
Fewer, there should be no restrictions at all (this is called a UBI)
@38LNC724yrs4Y
More, although ideally welfare should be eliminated and replaced by a UBI of some sort to eliminate negative incentives (welfare) and replace them with positive incentives.
@4ZTD62K4yrs4Y
Welfare as it is should be eliminated and replaced with local and community-based initiatives raised from local income, sales and property taxes.
@dandyman4yrs4Y
Fewer, and progressively provide aid according to need to ensure a smooth transition off of welfare
@6K8N8XC4yrs4Y
Replace welfare with universal basic income to remove the incentive structure to remain poor in the current welfare system
@6R6HBQ34yrs4Y
@6RW5J4M3yrs3Y
More, and replace welfare with a negative income tax
@75RKH4B4yrs4Y
Fewer, and replace most existing welfare benefits with a Universal Basic Income program
@6NRV2GV3yrs3Y
More restrictions, able-bodied people should not be able to receive welfare.
@6ZHJVTY4yrs4Y
Eliminate some of the red tape and wasted resources in this government agency. Make it possible to upload/email documents rather than fax. Favor hiring among those who receive(d) benefits.
@72KWJY74yrs4Y
Level, but reform benefits to grade away, instead of current income cliffs.
@Nbonner4yrs4Y
Replace the current welfare system with a negative income tax
@7W3SBDC4yrs4Y
Abolish and create a UBI instead.
@826WWJK4yrs4Y
Fewer, and reform the welfare system to be universal public services.
@85QWNPG3yrs3Y
Abolish welfare, un-ban high density public housing construction and provide both universal healthcare and a small UBI to all citizens as a dividend of investment on their providing to our prosperity
@86LT58K4yrs4Y
Replace with a universal basic income or negative income tax.
@EthanHars4yrs4Y
Repeal and replace with UBI
@warlock675434yrs4Y
It should be abolished and replaced by a UBI
@8CN7P7L4yrs4Y
More, do drug test and give it to immigrants that pay taxes
@8CQ4NFX4yrs4Y
I'm in the middle but they should be more depending on the situation as in do back ground checks and drug tests and if they are positive for illegal drugs or have a habit of dropping jobs often then yes more restrictions but if they don't fall in line with either of these things then fewer to no more restrictions.
@856VK5C4yrs4Y
Neither, rework the system from the ground up to provide a safety net for all citizens and residents along the lines of a UBI
@8DG8JPX4yrs4Y
There should be no welfare benefits from the federal level
@8HJ6ZY74yrs4Y
Switch to negative income tax
@8HK5TN24yrs4Y
@8HX2KD54yrs4Y
The government should only subsidize individuals who are unable to work.
@8KLLCKT4yrs4Y
The welfare system needs reform as many recipients don’t do what is needed to be removed from it.
@8KRN6JB4yrs4Y
I don't think restrictions should be made. However, there should be a time cap put on the program. The program should be used to get back on your feet, not to live off of for the rest of your life.
@8KP8Q9T4yrs4Y
More, but only increase by a little bit.
@8LG9WPJ4yrs4Y
Increases only for the elderly and the disabled. Reform the system, ensure welfare recipients are actively doing what they need to do to remove themselves from welfare. Oversight needs to be better. A pipeline out of the system needs to be created to limit dependency on welfare. welfare should not be lifelong.
@abbymayart4yrs4Y
More, but increase for elderly and disabled, add a drug screening, deny to illegal immigrants, use as a replacement for 6 months and then drop to a supplemental.
@8NXSCW24yrs4Y
Fewer, reform the system so that it supplements, rather than replaces a working income, but increase for the elderly and physically disabled.
@8NY4BWF4yrs4Y
People should be incentivized to get off of welfare not incentivized to have more children and stay home because that is more cost effective. I would have to see how the budget for welfare is managed in order to give a better answer, but if you want people to be productive you should incentivize them to do so.
@BiiiigOlTitties4yrs4Y
We should replace welfare programs with a basic income/citizen's dividend.
@buday4vancouver4yrs4Y
Fewer, so long as not conflating the truly disabled (not those self destructing on a vice).
@8PD23XN3yrs3Y
More, but move towards a UBI instead
@8PMF46F4yrs4Y
Regardless, there needs to be a major revamp of the welfare system as it encourages individuals to live in poverty and have as many children as possible.
@8RB2K9D4yrs4Y
More, but increase benefits for the elderly and disabled, and reform the system so that it supplements, rather than replaces, a working income
@8SG6GF54yrs4Y
The loopholes attached to qualifications needs to be closed.
@8SXLF6T3yrs3Y
Get rid of the current welfare system and replace it with a Negative Income Tax.
@8T9X24H3yrs3Y
Fewer, Welfare should be replaced with more specific programs.
@8TB798W3yrs3Y
More, and the goal should be to eliminate all government welfare.
@8TVSNS63yrs3Y
I don't have enough information at the moment to create my own opinon.
@8VC7WDN3yrs3Y
More, cap benefits so no one leaches off welfare forever; increase benefits for the elderly and disabled; remove and deny immigrants, especially illegal immgrants, from welfare programs; make it supplemental rather than a replacement for work income.
@8VL9DP43yrs3Y
I just feel like there should be benefits for those who need it.
@8VTBF8J3yrs3Y
We don't need less or more benefits or restrictions, just correctly directed benefits. Any benefit given by the federal government should be precise. An example: Food stamps should be more like WIC, as some food stamps are used to buy junk food, instead of the much needed fruits, vegetables, grains, and meats needed.
@8WFV28T3yrs3Y
eliminate welfare and just offer a basic income
@8WRCSMR3yrs3Y
Add more benefits for all types of people and situations
@8XD6BY63yrs3Y
More, but I’d prefer that the welfare system be abolished.
@8XD6BY63yrs3Y
More, but I’d prefer that the welfare system be abolished
@8YB8NY33yrs3Y
More, but I’d prefer the welfare system be abolished.
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.