Discussions
@ISIDEWITHDiscuss this answer...2yrs2Y
Much better
Better
Worse
Much worse
Same
Join in on more popular conversations.
@ISIDEWITH submitted…7 days7D
Trump proposed unprecedented U.S. control of Gaza Strip during a White House press conference with Netanyahu, suggesting "long-term ownership" that could last 10-15 years.The plan calls for nearly two million Palestinian residents to permanently relocate to neighboring countries, marking a dramatic shift from decades of U.S. policy.Congressional leaders from both parties expressed skepticism, with even Trump ally Lindsey Graham calling the proposal "problematic."Middle East experts, including former Palestinian Authority advisor Khaled Elgindy, criticized the plan as "bizarre and incoherent."White House officials argue mass relocation is the only viable option and seek to convince Egypt and Jordan to accept displaced Palestinians.The administration estimates Gaza reconstruction would take 10-15 years, far longer than the 3-5 years outlined in cease-fire agreements.The proposal lacks clear details on how to handle Palestinian resistance to relocation or potential U.S. military deployment.Saudi Arabia immediately rejected the plan, stating it wouldn't normalize ties with Israel without a clear path to Palestinian statehood.Trump expressed uncertainty about the current cease-fire's durability while presenting his proposal.The plan faces significant implementation challenges and could complicate other regional objectives, including Israel-Saudi normalization efforts.
▲ 2421 replies
First flight of detained migrants from U.S. to Guantanamo Bay departed Tuesday from Fort Bliss, carrying approximately twelve migrantsTrump administration plans to expand the migrant detention facility from current 120-person capacity to hold up to 30,000Approximately 200 Marines have been deployed to Guantanamo, with numbers expected to increase to 500 to help set up infrastructureThe base has historically maintained a small migrant detention facility since the 1990s, separate from its terror suspect prisonCurrent operation costs include $28,500 per hour for C-17 flights, compared to $8,500 for standard ICE flightsPrevious contractor Akima received contract worth up to $163.4 million to manage facility for just dozens of migrantsDefense Secretary Pete Hegseth, a former guard at the base, endorsed it as "perfect place" for migrant detentionDHS Secretary Noem promised "due process" but declined to rule out family detentionInternational Refugee Assistance Project has documented poor conditions including mold, sewage problems, and restricted communicationsLegal experts raise questions about how immigration cases would be adjudicated at the military base
▲ 89 replies
@ISIDEWITH submitted…6 days6D
Trump proposes a "Verified Nuclear Peace Agreement" with Iran, expressing preference for diplomacy over military action and calling for immediate negotiations.Despite advocating for diplomacy, Trump simultaneously issued an executive order reinstating his "maximum pressure" sanctions policy from his first administration.The sanctions campaign aims to completely halt Iran's oil exports, particularly focusing on exports to China, which currently receives about 1.7 million barrels per day.Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi responded by calling the maximum pressure strategy a "failed experience" while indicating openness to discussions about their nuclear program.The executive order includes reviewing and potentially rescinding existing sanctions waivers, including those related to the Chabahar port project operated by India.Iranian oil exports had previously dropped from 3 million barrels per day in 2018 to 420,000 barrels per day in December 2019 under Trump's first-term sanctions.Iran currently maintains a "shadow fleet" of oil tankers operating outside Western banking and insurance services to circumvent US restrictions.Oil markets showed limited reaction to Trump's announcement, with Brent crude dropping 1% as traders doubt the ability to completely block Iranian exports.Analysts suggest Iran could become a negotiating tool in US-China trade discussions, with China potentially willing to reduce Iranian oil imports as it modernizes its refining sector.Iranian analysts indicate Tehran would likely reject any agreement attempting to restrict their ballistic missile program, which they consider their primary deterrent.
▲ 1510 replies
Zelensky attacked Tucker Carlson on Piers Morgan's show, accusing him of "working for Putin"Direct quote: Zelensky told Carlson to "stop licking his [Putin's] ass"Zelensky claimed Carlson repeats Putin's talking points verbatimResponse was to Carlson's criticism of Zelensky's treatment of political opponentsCarlson also criticized treatment of Ukrainian Orthodox ChurchZelensky suggested Carlson needs deeper understanding of Ukraine situationAccused Carlson of misinforming/disinforming peopleQuestioned if Carlson had experienced personal lossSeparate topic: Zelensky claimed Trump invited him to inaugurationSaid invitation was general, declined as personal meeting unlikely
▲ 189 replies1 disagree
Jon Stewart criticized Democrats for repeatedly using Chuck Schumer as their spokesperson against Trump, calling his performances ineffective and monotonous.Stewart mocked Schumer's response to Trump's trade war threats, particularly his simplistic explanation about Mexican imports like Corona beer and avocados.The former Daily Show host expressed frustration at Schumer's basic observation that "guacamole is made of avocados" as a response to complex trade policy issues.Stewart sarcastically highlighted the Democrats' poor strategic choice in selecting Schumer to counter Trump, whom he described as "one of the most savvy presidential media manipulators in history."The comedian ridiculed Schumer's appearance and presentation style, particularly mocking his use of reading glasses positioned low on his nose.Stewart's criticism centered on the Democratic leadership's judgment in repeatedly choosing an "uninteresting" and "monotone" spokesperson.The commentary addressed Trump's threats of tariffs against Canada and Mexico, though focused more on the Democratic response than the policy itself.Stewart used hyperbole to emphasize his point, stating that Schumer's speaking makes him "want to bomb Canada."The piece highlighted the perceived disconnect between Democratic messaging strategy and effective opposition to Trump's policies.Stewart's criticism suggested a broader frustration with Democratic leadership's media strategy and public presentation.
▲ 4817 replies
Sen. Rand Paul publicly opposed Trump's Gaza proposal, criticizing it as contradicting "America First" principlesTrump suggested seizing control of Gaza and potentially deploying U.S. troops to transform it into a "Riviera of the Middle East"Secretary Rubio supported Trump's vision, promoting the idea of "Making Gaza Beautiful Again"Trump expressed willingness to send U.S. troops to Gaza if deemed necessary for securityTrump plans to take control of and develop parts of Gaza according to his statementsSpeaker Mike Johnson showed preliminary support for Trump's proposal while awaiting detailsDemocrats hold leverage through control of U.S. weapons sales to IsraelDemocratic lawmakers have halted a $1 billion arms sale to IsraelThe blocked arms sale includes 1,000-pound bombs and Caterpillar armored bulldozersPaul warned against "another occupation" that would cost American lives and resources
▲ 3016 replies
